Do fines make sense, other than a way for local governments to make money?

What, besides governmental money makers, are fines? If something’s a crime, should not the penalty be jailtime, if it’s not severe enough to warrant such, why cause a person to pay a fine, provided no one is hurt?

27 responses to “Do fines make sense, other than a way for local governments to make money?”

  1. What did you do…this time?

    Reply

    Loading spinner
  2. griz says:

    The principal is sound.

    Even if in the particular incident nobody got hurt.

    It is a time-honored exercise in substitutionary consequence. It has far more ability to invite learning and change then just a verbal warning or a finger wag.

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • Jear77 says:

      @griz would you feel the same way if you knew the only point to doing so was to get politicians rich, and make you poor?

      Reply

      Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        The last I checked, fines are very easy to not get!

        Just as one has choice in criminal activity that results in a record.

        Or in avoiding negative spiritual consequence.

        There is a common theme Here of accountability and taking responsibility for oneself; and not trying to blame others when we choose poorly.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz what is a traffic ticket?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        The result of us making a poor choice.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz What I was trying to get you to say is that a ticket is AMAZINGLY easy to get. And at day’s end it is nothing but a fine.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        I’ve never got a ticket or fine that wasn’t a result of my own poor choice!

        It’s amazingly easy to think that the rules don’t apply to me! Or to remain ignorant to the laws around me; or under play our species need for them, just because they might inconvenience me.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz There’s *also* entrapment. And it’s becoming increasingly a problem

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        The fear of some choosing a lower path, shouldn’t take us along for their ride!

        I would choose to see the value in even the attempt to govern wisely. And if the day comes again where I might have to face the reality that Humans do some very Human things, I will deal with it by seeking to rise above.

        Something else worth being saved from, is the constant fear of people being . . . . people! The fear that others might take a low path around me . . . doesn’t have to own me or keep me from the path I wish to take.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz How can you prevent being taken from a path when you’re behind a jail cell? At day’s end the point of entrapment is to feed the machine that is the privatization of the criminal justice system or to make the fines so prohibitively expensive that the defendants can’t get out of it without paying for a lawyer, and being paid for every prisoner behind bars, or, having the defendants pay an exorbitant fine.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        As I said, the fear of others doing what Humans are prone to do is something one might consider the need to be “saved” from.

        Laws can be accidentally broken. But wise jurisprudence would take this into account. One would have to present themselves as a considerable threat to society to be incarcerated as you are implying.

        Now I try to understand how different US jurisprudence is from that in Canada. Frankly, it leaves me scratching my head more times than I can count. I do however know a considerable number of Americans who know and at least try to respect the laws — even the ones they might not like or find convenient! And they don’t live in constant fear of being incarcerated. So it is possible — perhaps even easy — to NOT be thrown in jail! (But I understand that ego complicates this).

        But if your system is that predatory and corrupt, why not get away from it? I believe freedom of movement is still enjoyed in the US?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz I would look at how many cases are overturned, the innocent victims of overzealous prosecutors and officers of the law coercing false confessions of guilt if I were you. If I WERE to move, I’d probably move to the Netherlands and become naturalized there. But I’d need a job such that I could afford to live, as 50%+ of the income is taken as taxes.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Maybe they’ve consumed too many Hollywood legal shows and have become what they ate? :rolf:

        The US is a rather unique case, I’ll give you that. And Humans being what they are, mistakes do happen.

        Should a false accusation or corrupt system find me incarcerated at ABSOLUTELY no fault of my own, I would explore what that new chapter in my life would be; and be consoled that incarceration is an entirely different creature than what it was in the days of Daniel, Paul and Silas! And even those chapters in their lives yielded good kingdom fruit.

        (And if there was some fault of mine, I would learn from it and then proceed to the step above! So what would you do? Sit there and fume about it? Let it negatively own the rest of your life?)

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz actually what you’re seeing in Hollywood is simply art imitating art, not the other way around.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        What if it were more life imitating life?

        You more than most, should appreciate the effects of art on the lives of its partakers. Ultimately, that is what an artist strives for.
        And that is what we reward artists for. Whether in paying millions for a painting; or awarding it high Neilson ratings or lots of “likes”.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz While I enjoy “likes” and (constructive) criticism as much as the next artist, most of my writing is more for ME than it is for the audience I’m writing for,

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        My artistic expressions started like this too. Over years they changed to include more than just my needs.

        But only after I grew confident of my ability to both reach and touch people on-demand (ie, it wasn’t just a fluke).

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz It’s not that I CAN’T… I just don’t care to put my time and energy towards something that I don’t have the expertise with to begin with. For instance, if I go on Ultius, I’m not going to take an assignment that I don’t have enough time to do, or force myself into an artificial form, like a premade outline. And when I WAS taking assignments on a (more) regular basis, I often found that I had to TOTALLY stop my life to do the research to get the writing done in the time frame that they asked me to write it in. For me, writing is a thing that takes however long it takes. If I’m rushed, I might be able to turn it in, but I’ll give a subpar product, and I’m not willing to do so.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        In photography, it takes as long as it takes. (Sometimes even longer. Just getting the perfect moment is only the start of the process).

        But I never tried to do it as my main income source. If I broke even on the cost of the trip that resulted in the picture, I was content.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz When I write, I typically try to do a solid draft, simply moving things around as I need to, not do a ton of heavy edits afterwards. But typically the way I write for pay is intro copy+ paste, condense, & edit, conclusion if needed to make my point as a start. But I do take my original ideas and flesh them out (there was a writer’s digest magazine article I used to have that my parents threw out that used FLESH as an acrostic.)

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Whether by accident or design, my first artistic outlet couldn’t be created from thin air. I had to get off my chair and get moving. At first there was no guarantee that anything on that journey would prove a suitable target. (Odds improved with experience, but even years later I can still come up dry with only a pleasant ramble for my troubles).

        Then there’s always the possibility that what I envisioned in my mind, didn’t translate well into picture. I always insisted on a certain natural quality to my photos and wouldn’t create something “unnatural” in edit and pass it off as something natural.
        So some trips still come up dry.

        But even if I produce a remarkable image, I still have to distinguish it from everyone else’s — including some that are more fake than “real”.

        It’s an interesting artistic expression. I’m not sure if I chose it . . . or it chose me!

        Reply

        Loading spinner
  3. Fletch says:

    it further separates the haves and the have-nots.

    that’s what money does.

    Reply

    Loading spinner
  4. BelleMadre says:

    i got my first fine this year, for having an out of date license for my house pet. laaaaaaaaaaaaaaame (in the end the fine was thrown out and i just paid for her papers … also lame?!) :tease:

    Reply

    Loading spinner

Leave a Reply

I am an avid writer (mainly RPG stuff), and love to cook.

More Conversations

Search the Site