Personally, I think these are good things.
But I read an article where a “Pride” protest, attracted protesters.
Who were peaceful and simply expressing their concerns and beliefs just as the Pride people were.
But they all were instantly condemned as “haters”. Why did one group have “all the rights” afforded them, and another castigated for doing essentially the same thing?
So the questions.
-Can you be crying for and demonstrating your freedoms, while denying the same to others?
-What should happen when your freedom to movement in public areas (roadways, bridges, downtown cores) infringes upon the freedom of movement in others who have chosen to take care of the stuff that puts food on the table and a roof over the head?
-And is someone automatically “a hater” . . . because they have a differing opinion or don’t rush to validate and massage you were you are?
© 2026 – SoulSequel
23 responses to “Freedom of Speech, Movement and Expression”
I think the phrase peaceful protest is an oxymoron in this day and age.
The example you used is infused with passionate (and not in the healthiest context of the word) commentary to ignite emotional hyperbole which inevitably spirals downwards.
Everybody should be entitled to raise awareness (pro or con) of their validated beliefs. That they should be done there at the same time might be the issue.
Even when hateful groups assemble, protestors who display the same hateful response to hate, only fuel a fire rather than douse it.
The main issue, in my opinion, is mob mentality on either side of the equation. This sense of security in numbers leads to base human instincts taking precedence over sound, objective resistance.
The solution? Leadership that uses a shared voice platform that can manage a message with intellect and clarity. No toe to toe confrontation. No in your face emotional outbursts. Just sound, objective, calm expression of an alternative point of view.
The challenge on our planet at the moment is that there are very few leaders that have the capacity to think through their positions beyond how it plays to their followers. It has become less about positive change and awareness, as it is about retention of power.
Absolute power corrupts, no matter what theater of control one is managing. From a demented pastor to a delusional politician. Succumbing to anger illustrates a very weak leader that transfers through to their followers.
It seems so obvious to me, but few people want to step up when it’s also easy to see it is a huge battle. First you have the opposition to contend with and worse, the self orientation of the followers of ones particular movement. It’s a stacked deck.
@spitfire3dc
There is a time and place to make a stand for what we believe in. But it’s as if some have become addicted to doing so, loudly and publically, every chance they get.
And there’s something questionable about the process where we think the only way something can stand is if we’re constantly propping it up: sort of like straw men always have to be propped up.
Hate breeds hate — perhaps even the hate to call everyone else who doesn’t stand to prop something up with you, “haters”? Fear begets fear. And the dance of oppressed and oppressor is one that has locked our species into a death-spiral for long enough . . . imho.
We don’t solve social issues . . . so much as we just let the other team play with the sun to their back for a while.
Good leadership is part of the issue. But what is the best way to lead?
By example.
And in a world where our hired leaders are too busy playing games and keeping the factions balanced, they don’t have a lot of energy left to set good example. Just as the parents of a spoiled and demanding (entitled?) child are always on the edge of stress trying to keep all the plates spinning. To come up with better strategies to deal with the children distracted by the plates spinning might mean letting a few of them fall!
And then the kids protest!
Good leaders delegate . . . to responsible people.
And perhaps in a society that seems bent on abdicating responsibility (beyond protesting!), there are precious few responsible people to be found?
Are our leaders going to lead those who want to be their own leaders out of this? Do we still need “messiahs” to lead us to “promised lands”?
Or should we all be taking responsibility for the promise that is right here before us every day?
The difference is that one group Is part of oppressing a group that has been oppressed for a great many years, and the other is not
@Scarlett
And then the teams switch sides on the exact same playing field!
The problem is that very few oppressors feel they are oppressors at the time. Most consider themselves “necessary champions”! Much as many current social movements that are spinning out-of-control consider themselves “necessary champions”.
Complicate this with the cycle of abuse; and the very valid observation that groups liberated from oppression, very quickly set out to do the same; to sit in that same seat of power over others . . . even over the society.
There are many examples in various social movements that have arisen to deal with “oppressions” and in their own unique way, begin the same march of oppression against others.
Actually, it’s rare for a social movement that gains voice and power to not have the power go to seed in them and become twisted variants of the same thing they rose to combat.
Some with lightning speed. Look at BLM. Almost out of the gates, they were using incalictrant criminal activity . . . to protest that incalcitrant criminal activity too often resulted in perpetrators getting shot! Or escaping this, over-populating the prisons.
(I know now it’s not as cut-and-dried as this. But the inherent silliness of the situation is now actively working against them).
The cycle we’re trapped and spinning down in . . . isn’t working.
If you’re going to protest against something that society as a whole has accepted, your freedom of speech may come with consequences. Protesting against something such, even peaceably may arouse ire. Do you want the ire or not? Is what you’re standing against worth it? Go ahead! If not? Don’t protest.
@Jear77
My thought is that anyone starting out on such a course needs to perform a periodic check on themselves/”the movement” with check-boxes like
-have we made good strides towards getting laws/opinions changed?
-have we become our own variant of the very “social injustice” we rose to combat?
-are we riding high on the emotions of being “necessary champions”?
-are we still going about this in a logical and rational way — or have feelings, emotions and passions taken the reigns?
-are we just looking for more battles and conflicts to try to keep the ride going?
And there remains, very effective ways to become champions against social unjustice . . . than just standing in a group in a public place and crying “Waaaa!!”.
The problem is . . . emotional reactionism makes for good viewing!
But it wasn’t that long ago that we knew the best way to stop a child throwing a tantrum . . . was to not given them the attention they craved until they improved their behavior!
Freedom of speech is a two edged sword…
Say whatever you like, you have the right, and everyone else has the right to ignore what you said. It happens to me all the time.
You have the right to yell FIRE in a crowded theater…but should you? Probably not.
Freedom of assembly, freedom of expression of grievances you wish to redress, and freedom to march for a cause are all protected under the 1st amendment (in the U.S.).
But in doing so, if you become violent, attack others with violence, and destroy private property your actions are no longer protected under the 1st amendment.
@immortal_pirate
It’s different in Canada. We don’t have the specific right to protest in so many words.
It’s a mating of the right to free speech, the right to congregate peacefully and freedom of movement. (Bit of a 3-way 3-some!)
The interesting thing about Truth, is that it finds the ears of those who seek it while those who reject Truth remain deaf to it.
So the question then, is whether protests of histrionics are of Truth that can stand; or falseshoods that need constant propping up?
Freedoms are a good thing. But wisdom is an even finer thing. Just because one has the right to do something, does that mean it’s a wise thing to be doing?
@immortal_pirate
I’ve never yelled fire, but I have yelled “BURN DOWN THE SCHOOL” in a packed auditorium assembly.
I don’t have to go out and loudly protest. We have a Police Department to handle those who get unruly. We have voting rights.
Block traffic and someone will lose patience with that and ram through your lines — running you over for standing in the street.
Protesting becomes violent when the posts holding up your signs are used as clubs to bash others and beat the people with opposing views to the ground. You cannot beat another person into changing their view of you. If you think someone is wrong, beating them will not make them right. If you think someone is stupid, beating them will not make them smart. Beating and violence will not make you right.
@ladybarbara A pictures worth a thousand words…
@immortal_pirate
It’s hard to win an argument with a moving bumper; despite your stated “rights”.
In older times we would “demonstrate”. Yea, there were shades of satisfaction for self but concern for the society and the greater whole were the motivation. The “vehicle” was education; and was driven with a modicum of respect for others in the area.
Now we have protests. And they seem mostly about placation of the self with just shades of concern for the society and the greater whole. Emotion and outrage, disrespect and too often destruction are the vehicle; and they don’t seem to care who they run over with it. (Was that window they just broke, on the shop of someone who is “against them”? Or did the property of someone formerly supporting your cause just get in the way of your emotion-charged brick?)
Even if we set the destruction aside, blocking multiple people from getting to work and other destinations, is NOT the way to get them to consider what you might be saying . . . . kindly! So the concern is not for the society or the issue; because you are turning people off and making your cause a pariah.
The main outcome, is “Boy, I feel good for doing that!”.
@immortal_pirate @griz
So fuck Heather Heyer huh?
Tunnel-vision & a lack of empathy go hand in hand.
A philosophy that finds justification in killing for being inconvenienced is a tad, completely, kinda, vividly, sorta, thoroughly FuCked!
@luftballooneyegouge
Tunnel vision is not examining beyond what our eyes are already focused on. As in, it becomes the only thing we see.
I am not underplaying someone dying for what they TRULY BELIEVE IN.
I am however, inviting people to see beyond what they are already focused on. What did she die for? What did she believe in and give her life for? A righteous stance? A political stance? A “feeling nice” stance?
Ponder and answer carefully.
Because if she did truly believe this was a righteous stance worth any sacrifice, then there is no better death than in the service of a cause greater than just self. This is not a moment for sadness and tragedy, but for celebration.
But if this is just a moment for sadness and tragedy, the necessary conclusion is that this was just some kind of leisure activity who’s prime function was to produce temporary “feel-good” — ad get noticed doing so.
So are we a FuCked yet? Was she there for some purpose so noble, that it was worth dying for?
Or was she tragically killed just for wanting to “have fun”?
Hero . . . or self-seeker?
Perhaps the world would be a better place if EVERYONE undertaking a “noble protest” where they dream themselves as the “necessary hero”, would stop and weigh if this is truly an important cause worth dying for . . . or just a social masturbation.
For the main tragedy, in dying just for the latter.
@griz
No. A girl was killed and you come up with shit like,
“It’s hard to win an argument with a moving bumper; despite your stated “rights”.
You bringing up her intent is a deflection from the fact that there’s a “conservative” “mind”-set that this is justifiable homicide. All this other shit ‘gurgitating up is tertiary to the highest levels.
Blame the victim, wash, rinse, & repeat…
@luftballooneyegouge
A lot to work through there. No, I’m not playing sides in some political game.
Yes. Someone was killed. So I choose to honor both the way she choose to live and what she choose to die for.
And even if it “offends”, we benefit from extracting all we can from her final moments in this reality. Anything else would be to dishonor her final walk.
Even if what we learn . . . doesn’t give us the feelings we want.
So what positive lesson can you share from it?
Was she a victim . . . or a hero?
Was this a stance important enough to die for?
Nor not so much?
@ladybarbara
If one is always protesting loudly, people respond over time by just turning down the volume on everything you say.
A klaxxon loses it’s effectiveness if you’re honking it all the time!
Whereas a few soft words from a person known for their quite wisdom . . . gets attention. Plus, Truth is a weighty thing. It stands on its own without propping up and is still there even after many blow-hards have taken aim at it.
So seek wisdom, and speak Truth. Then you won’t need to go out and loutly protest.
(The spelling mistake is intentional!)
….condemned as “haters”?
Is this a social-media-identity-validation concern?
Who cares if one gets labeled as a hater? I’ll wear that label like a Wham t-shirt.
The best form of protest are big ass banquets for the poor, but our stupid-ass suckciety is so drenched in military drool, that we do parades and rallies,… for peace. Might as well have marching bands and shoot off a goddamn paisley cannon.
@luftballooneyegouge
No, it’s more about rejection and dismissal as a censorship tool. It only damages you to the extent you let it. The ones using it, and the ones not recognizing it’s being used sustain the most damage from it.
It creates a very effective way of quickly censoring any voices that might have valid concerns for the society but are not massaging the current pop-notions of whichever special-interest group might have control of the media at the time.
The boo-boos it might inflict on our feelings are not the issue. The issue is it’s being used as a very effective censorship tool — and a tool for closing the minds of the shallow-thinkers who wait for the media (and to a lesser degree, scientists) to tell them what they are allowed to think.
And like it or not, any lasting social change HAS to educate and bring such people along with the rest of us. Leaving them behind is not an option.
This is in the same censorship category as calling something “fake news” just because it says something that you might not want to hear!
@griz
Censorship is stopping someone from saying something, not disagreeing with it or turning it off.
Why incorporate hyperbole into a philosophy?
@luftballooneyegouge
So is it nothing akin to censorship when we commit it upon ourselves?
Consider that crying “hater” or “fake news” as first (and final?) recourse . . . are very effective ways of “turning off” interactions with viewpoints valuable for remaining “part of the whole” and not just splitting off into the kind of factions that any enemy just LOVES to see in their prey.
@griz
HATER!
FAKE NEWS!
Nope. I can still see your text.
@luftballooneyegouge
That’s enough emotion to make my words shrink into insignificance in the mind.
But genuine histrionics may be necessary to make you totally blind to them!