Given a choice would you rather be born into the upper 97 percentile of wealthy families, or with Ann IQ in the upper 97%?

Run the scenario forwards 40 years.
Which you do you think would be better off?

Would you still choose the same if you knew an economic collapse or some other great leveling event was about to happen?

25 responses to “Given a choice would you rather be born into the upper 97 percentile of wealthy families, or with Ann IQ in the upper 97%?”

  1. Jear77 says:

    I am assuming you mean “an iq” not “ann iq”
    There is a no longer updating webcomic entitled Mindmistress. It doesn’t have the greatest artwork, but its premise is as follows: a mentally challenged woman (IQ 66) gets a technology based necklace that multiplies her intelligence such that she is able to be a super inventor. She creates a nanobot suit that amplifies her strength, and also creates a field that slows the inertia of fast objects (or herself); a staff to hypnotize her foes, and AI vehicles made of the same materials of her suit. But the drawback is that she needs to return to her mentally challenged state or die of brain cancer.
    If super intelligence allowed me to do things like that, sure!

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • griz says:

      @Jear77
      “an IQ”. It was a dictating software error that I didn’t catch.

      And I am not talking a fantasy construct from a story. I’m talking about the actual asset of IQ manifest in reality. There are more than enough accredited studies and theses on the measurably positive effect high IQ has on a vast array of life factors . . . to keep this grounded in reality.

      Reply

      Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz remember IQ does nothing in and of itself. Idiot savants have a high IQ in one area, but no skills in others. EQ (emotional quotient) is equally important

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        How can you cite such an example without recognizing the exceptional accomplishment IQ renders in such situations.

        Are you back on the kick of “it must do everything” for it to be considered in any way meaningful??

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz really? Do i *also* have to site that most of these people can’t even dress themselves without assistance?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        If a high IQ savant had just performed some amazing feat . . . far beyond what most people could do . . . would you walk up and try to invalidate it by saying, “Yea! But you can’t even dress yourself!”

        It would in no way invalidate what they’d just done.

        Do you think Stephen Hawking could dress himself?

        The point remains that high IQ mitigates and compensates for a lot of negative factors.

        Your map of meaning drives you to a lot of very bizarre reaches my friend. Isn’t it about time to rewrite it?

        its probably responsible for a lot more of your suffering than you realize.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz many. But not a lack of independence for me. Give me the ability to be on my own, totally without any roommates instead.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        If you’ve mainly had mooching roommates, you may not know the beneficial dynamic a good one can bring.

        Fellowship is always more work than isolation.

        But it also brings far more growth and positive benefits for both.

        And this segues back into other recent threads about a meaning [beyond self] that mitigates the suffering.

        Perhaps even makes it worthwhile?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz it’s too much headache. I deal with people at work. Let me enjoy my solitude when off

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        For everything there is a season. Including solitude.

        But a work dynamic is different in that I doubt you are in close personal relationship with coworkers and guests!

        And healthy fellowship does help strengthen an overly-sensitive suffering-trigger.

        Remembering that “healthy” means no one side is trying to “out-Loki” the other!

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz this guy who is my roommate/ boss needs to have a swift kick in the ass. He put all his hope and dreams on getting $2,000 to put as a downpayment for this restaurant project he’s doing… what happens when/ if it doesn’t work out? I don’t wish him ill, but there’s no way for me to fund that. And he doesn’t have a backup plan except his own death.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Big question then: is he paying rent?

        Responsibility and reliability start small; and work their way up to things like $2,000 down-payments.

        If he cannot be reliable and responsible with the smaller things (like car payments and rent) . . . what grounds is there to believe he will be reliable with larger projects?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz No.. the $2000 is only a “place holder” – it’s promissory money until the the loan for the $460,000 comes through, of which $190,000 is the actual purchase price of the restaurant.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Do you think he has the credit history and viable business plan to Warrant such a loan?

        default thing on an automobile loan is on notable black mark.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz it doesn’t matter. He’s not going to be in direct control of the $ – the controller is. No matter what i say he’ll push it through

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        It’s less a matter of you influencing or controlling him.

        Our only true authority (freedom) in life is to influence and control ourselves so the inherent nature of reality around us doesn’t drive us bonkers.

        We need a map of meaning that will allow this to happen.

        And that means getting rid of any maps of meaning that to date have not allowed this to happen.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz his currently is “if i don’t do this today, life isn’t worth living, therefore i must die.” Anything else he refuses to hear.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        I wonder when positive drive, turns into desperate obsession?

        It would be a different point for each person. There’s something to be said for perseverance.
        But how to recognize when it becomes a desperate flail?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz that’s what I was trying to tell him. I have zero good credit (I do everything in cash, and I had a series of bounced checks that they’ll be able to see). I have a feeling, even with me having a job, it won’t make a difference on this small loan,

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        I think that part of fellowship in a society of free thought and free speech is telling others what we see. Which is different from trying to tell them what to do.

        Which can be difficult if what we see is folly or even impending destruction . . . But their current map of meaning will patently not allow them to even see it over the pursuit of their assessed “meaningful” goal. (A goal that walks us to destruction off of proverbial cliff, is anti-meaningful)

        And two thoughts on this:
        1. At least we have shared faithfully in love. (Associated, rather than isolated)
        2. We are human too and could have a wrong perception: a flawed map of meaning that is patently not allowing us to see things right in front of us.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Life throws a lot of cautionary teachers before us.

        And it becomes our choice of what we are going to do with these educational moments.

        Are we going to take more away from them, than just a bit of feel-good that “at least I’m doing better than that”?

        Reply

        Loading spinner
  2. Spitfire3dC says:

    Seems an obvious choice to me.

    With a high iq you have a capacity to earn wealth, if that is a choice you have made, or you can use your iq to establish the objectives that would actually have some meaning in your life. That may include wealth Different strokes for different folks.

    Being born into wealth has its pros and cons. Some children get blessed with a better education and beyond that an understanding that goes beyond the superficiality of material gain. Some are given the benefit of being grounded. The other end of the spectrum are those who remain clueless to reality.

    To the second question, wealth is a relative thing. Always. In the event of an economic collapse. I think I would choose to start wealthy, lose a lot, but still have more than others, because it just might be an issue of survival. Survival instinct rules.

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • griz says:

      @spitfire3dc
      Having money can’t make you intelligent; but being intelligent can make you money if that is what you wish. And it is interesting the number of very intelligent people throughout history, who used their intelligence to advance species rather than just themselves.

      I don’t doubt the being born rich can open some doors. I may have an uncommon perspective on this, having worked closely with both underprivileged and overprivileged children at camps. My observation was that either wealth retards intellect, or a lack of wealth really encourages it.
      Plus a lot fewer people are ready to reach out to a child of wealth (except to profiteer!). They just figure their money will take care of them.

      Wealth might provide a buffer during the early stages of an economic collapse. But it would also make you more a target for looting. And what help would it be during a zombie apocalypse?

      I still think I would rather have the intelligence edge.

      Reply

      Loading spinner
  3. five2one says:

    We do not think in this ways.

    This test reminded me of tests on ravens.

    Whatever the case, I stick to family.

    Reply

    Loading spinner

Leave a Reply

Search the Site