R&B singer and teenage girl aficionado, R. Kelly is back in the news. R. Kelly allegedly has been running a sex cult made up of young women whom he took under his wing assuring that he’d make them famous. Apparently he keeps them all in the guest house in his backyard, doesn’t let them have cell phones, doesn’t let them contact there families, doesn’t let them leave the house without permission, and chooses who they can have sex with. There’s more and I’m just summing it up for brevity. You can read about it here in this incredibly disturbing buzzfeed article (https://www.buzzfeed.com/jimderogatis/parents-told-police-r-kelly-is-keeping-women-in-a-cult?utm_term=.xgZyE0ywa1#.st9K95KLGQ).
I know, I know. Buzzfeed. But Jim DeRogatis is a Chicago legend whose been uncovering bullshit for years now. Again, these are all allegations. Personally, I believe it. Nothing R. Kelly has done up to this point has suggested that he isn’t a particularly growdy shit-stain on humanity’s boxer briefs.
From a musical standpoint, I don’t care about R. Kelly. Not even “Ignition”. But a lot of people love R. Kelly the musician and seem to put R. Kelly the person on the back burner. Now, I’m not here to say you should stop listening R. Kelly. Do what you want, man. And if we really sat down and talked about all of the horrible things our favorite musicians have done, we’d all be in tears. But how far does it go for you?
I’ve always felt that as long as it wasn’t brought into the art, I could ignore John Lennon or Dr. Dre’s violent tendencies. But Dr. Dre has a history of writing songs about violence towards women. So, obviously there’s chunks of Dr. Dre’s work that I can’t get behind. However, when things like murder, rape, or sex cults enter into the mix of the artist’s personal life, I need to reconsider aspects of my fandom.
So where do you stand? Is it time we put R. Kelly in the trash? Is his personal life separate from his work? Are you still going bump “Ignition” at house parties?
PS – holy shit! 19 replies on my last post! I’ve been busy and haven’t been able to respond. Just know I’m not ignoring you guys and your responses are appreciated.
< 3
There are no more posts.
© 2026 – SoulSequel
11 responses to “How far can you separate the art from the artist?”
There is a band where one of the guys did something terrible. I loved the band, but I dropped all but one song of theirs. I just can’t totally depart with that song since I went through some times with it. Fuck that guy in general though.
There was a wrestler that killed part of his family and himself. He was a great wrestler, but WWE doesn’t mention him anymore and he will never be in their Hall of Fame. That is ok and very understandable.
I can respect the art myself, but the art won’t be promoted by me. They won’t be on my lists of “What are your top/favorite ____?” What they did was not ok, and I’m not spreading their work.
@yin Holy smokes, I didn’t know about Benoit. That’s so sad.
@mamajoy It is. It was so shocking see the card at the beginning of that WWE show saying he passed away. My uncle yelled, “WHAT!?” They even dedicated that entire show to him. Like, the show itself was canceled, but they ran footage of him and had other wrestlers talk about him and the stories they shared. The facts then started coming out as to what happened and they just dropped everything about him. Even have warnings before the shows that have him on the WWE Network. Personally, I think his concussions played a huge roll in what he did. That doesn’t really matter though outside of it needing to be studied. He still did what he did. It is a damn shame.
The public easily puts the fame of artists above the art, no question.
@Fletch Very true.
I can’t separate the two. To me, the expression of art is the expression of the artist.
On a tangent associated with this R. Kelly thing. I can’t see how anyone who becomes famous by today’s standards cannot go insane. When you are surrounded by an entourage that is hyper supportive and fanatics that are not far behind, you gotta go Michael Jackson/Kurt Cobain/Jim Morrison/WhitneyHouston…The human brain is incapable of retaining any semblance of rational objectivity when they are in a rarified atmosphere of surreality.
My best answer to this has to be very metaphysical: because music is a function of our creativity, and this is housed in our spirit (or our soul if it is still chained and imprisoned).
To partake of the creation is to partake of the spirit of its creator.
All music has messages in it beyond physical language. If the spirit or soul of the person creating the music is dark or toxic, it will be in the music and you will be taking of it.
To use some hyperbole, there are safe ways to render sewage safe for drinking. But why would you if there is pure(r) water available?
This is a dodgy enough pursuit if you can recognize these things and neutralize their toxicity. But it’s downright foolish if you can’t even discern the deeper spiritual messages. Because they will find a home in you, weaken you, and build up over time.
@griz Great answer.
I am not interested in music, or the artists, but I live with an artist. He takes an old piece of wood and brings out the music in the wood. He creates stringed instruments, like violins, banjo, lutes, guitars, and dulcimers. He created seagulls that are popular. He built a pirate ship that fills half of the dining room 8 ft long and 8 ft. tall. He built my greenhouse garden. There is a love that he puts in everything he builds. That is because there is a lot of love inside the artist and he loves his creations into being. People marvel at the intricate carvings and details on the pirate ship. As I am typing this, Immortal Pirate is talking to his brother about the brewing of beer, ale, and his famous mead —– which tastes like Johannesburg Riesling wine. He puts love into everything he creates and there is more love inside of him.
@ladybarbara
I don’t like R.Kelly so I think it’s time we put him in the trash. He is a creepshow that used his “fame” to mislead ignorant women.
As far as being able to separate the art from the artist – I really have a hard time with that one. I think the individual’s conduct and history has the biggest impact on my perspective of them.
This question makes me think about Michael Jackson. I think he wrote some amazing songs and I can fully appreciate what he did with his music. But then there’s the whole Neverland Ranch and child molestation allegations that are really fucked up. I recognize that as a child, he had likely suffered a lot of physical and emotional abuse. I find that I truly feel for the child that went through that. It doesn’t make his possible abuse towards children okay, by any means. But I also don’t hold him wholly responsible. These children had parents involved, the ranch was fully staffed, and there were countless others who could have stepped in if they truly felt that something was wrong. With that being said, I still have Michael Jackson songs in my shuffle list.