The most optimal place to be for learning, is right on the line between anxiety and curiosity.

There is a tie in to the Chinese philosophy of Yin and Yang, where one is most alive when they occupied the boundary between the two; between Order and Chaos.

Thoughts?

21 responses to “The most optimal place to be for learning, is right on the line between anxiety and curiosity.”

  1. Scarlett says:

    im not sure about this one. I think some people put too much pressure on themselves to learn a skill, making whatever knowledge is forthcoming not worth the trouble.

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • griz says:

      @Scarlett
      It was something I came across in a lecture. Unfortunately I’m finding there is often a difference between clinical and lay understanding of terms.
      Anxiety is not one of the base “primitive” motivations like hunger, thirst, anger, panic, attachment, exploration, play etc, but is a later addition with self-awareness. It needs an understanding of “future” which the rest of the animals don’t have. (Emotional anxiety is most often triggered over fear of future happenings)

      But roughly speaking, there is anxiety the conditioned brain response, and anxiety the emotion. They are linked but different. Pain and anger are similar, in that the line blurs between them being a motivational state and an emotion. (the behavior-circuit of pain tells us to “stop”, the behavior-circuit of anger tells us to remove/destroy an obstacle)

      It parses something like this. A University med student learns of a particular ailment and for whatever reasons, becomes driven, almost fixated on in. The curiosity (coming from the primitive hypothalamus) provides the “vehicle” that keeps moving foward (with curiosity being linked to dopamine “reward” response).
      But the “fuel” comes from the anxiety circuits in slightly newer brain (forget the name right now) that recognize this as a problem that needs solving, because people are suffering. The curiosity can only take the process so far.
      The same with my almost insatiable desire to study psychology. The curiosity is a major “rewarding” (dopamine) factor. But the “anxiety response” that fueled it was in seeing a serious social problem in the rise of various victimhood power groups. (Dopamine-reward was the positive force, the anxiety response the negative. Together, they balance)

      And I don’t know if the classic grading system in school was adopted to take advantage of this, or whether it was a purely pragmatic way to evaluate the successful internalization of information. But it serves a similar purpose. Kids can rarely connect learning math or spelling (if they still teach that??) with “a problem that needs to be solved”. But the thought of bringing home a failing grade still triggers the same anxiety behavioral circuits that fuel the “car” of learning.

      And then it gets into problems if the anxiety circuit in the brain adds up with other factors to produce anxiety the emotion. At which point one needs to assess whether to amend the way we teach, or to just teach people better skills for handling their emotions.

      It seems that such a skill would be a valuable lifetime asset to apply in all situations of learning AND negative emotional response to whatever. Whereas “nice-i-fying” the teaching process in no way precludes them having a learning situation later in life that has not be sufficiently “nice-i-fied” and triggers the same emotional response that they have not been trained to master.

      Reply

      Loading spinner
  2. Jear77 says:

    A place between…
    “curiosity killed the cat, but satisfaction brought it back”
    “be anxious for nothing.”
    hm
    how?

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • griz says:

      @Jear77
      Getting tired, so the brain isn’t working right. But the idea is that our processes are most “alive” when they are on the edge of order and chaos. Or we are most balanced at the line where Yin and Yang meet.

      Consider the question, is anxiety (or pain or anger) a brain-process that triggers the emotion; or an emotion that triggers the brain-process? That’s a very complex question. Physiologically in the brain they are related, but different. The pain/avoidance brain-process can be triggered without generating the emotion we often consider as “pain”. Same with the anger/prepare for battle response. It can happen without triggering the emotion that so often just puts us out of control.

      We are primed for optimal learning, when there is both the positive and the negative brain-process present, but in balance.

      Reply

      Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz OK, I think I get your point.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        ( after some sleep and thought!)

        If it remains too much in the realm of control, we are learning nothing new: just reinforcing existing knowledge, processes and subpersonalities.

        If it goes too deeply into chaos the low-level anxiety/stress process necessary to create new cortical pathways processes and subpersonalities (mapping on to the positive play and exploration centers of the Primitive brain), twists negative and maps onto the pain and panic centers.

        The curiosity reflex is overshadowed by the avoidance reflex.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz I have VERY bad memory, which you yourself have commented on. I really don’t “learn” anything new per se, outside of what I already know, as I have to purposely forget things to remain in the present. In school I acquired the trick of retaining information for the exact amount of time needed… then the moment the class is over, if it isn’t accessed, it gets forgotten. That’s why I can read my own articles as if they’re someone else’s, because I forgot what I wrote.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        A lot of things can give the impression of bad memory. And not just things congenital, but things we can do something about.

        But you obviously have a good enough memory you are (hopefully!) not running into walls, falling down stairs , touching hot stoves, running into traffic, putting bees in your mouth, sticking sharp objects up your nose, burning yourself on hot drinks, wearing a diaper, and are communicating in passable English . . . Not to mention coming up with an impressive array of excuses!
        Your memory may not be eidetic, or even average ( though I suspect it is). And it’s certainly not as poor as some of the challenge children I’ve worked with over the years.

        There comes a time when we have to decide if we are going to put our effort into making excuses, or just doing what is necessary to give life meaning.

        I’m tackling a complex psychology course with learning disabilities that may not be too different from your own; and with an array of coping skills you are either familiar with or could benefit from knowing.

        Not exercising even the bit that we may have, leaves us with even less at the end of each day. Complex systems tend to either grow or atrophy.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz actually growing up, i was at constant risk of falling. I had *really* weak ankles. My sense of balance almost always saved me tho. On the rare instances where it didn’t, i ended up eating pavement. To thus day, if i am stressed, you can see a goose-egg on my forehead where i fell.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Hope your head heals quickly!

        I have a trick ankle that can rather mercilessly throw me to the ground for no apparent reason. My ribs still remind me of the time it pitched me off a 7-foot cliff for no reason.

        But remember what I said about our focus defining ourexperienced reality? Vast tracts of our subconscious landscape can be programmed to render a “reality” that is constrained and twisted unto a focus we’ve attached efficient meaning to.

        I see a lot of people in society with a focus on things like infirmities, ailments, tribal politics and victimhood. And they give it enough meaning, that they become twisted.
        We can be aware of these things in us and account for them, without them becoming a focus strong enough to work subconsciously against us.

        Managing subconscious incongruities is a major drain on resources. Resolve them, and one suddenly has more internal resources to devote to more meaningful projects of conscious intent.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz so my solution to *accept* all my own incongruities/ hypocrisy is perfect!

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        Accepting a turd that has been shipped to you, is not the same as doing something about it.

        And doing something about it is not the same as doing something constructive with it!

        And doing something constructive with it, may not be the same as doing something efficiently constructive with it.

        Accepting that something exists — even yourself — is not the same as doing something efficiently constructive with it.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz as a side note: remember your other question regarding is it possible to have too much learning… one thing the “riches” philosophy teaches is that you can’t get to point x by knowing about/ studying/ thinking about point y (its opposition/ reverse / inverse). So in order to be rich, all knowledge of poverty must be eliminated. To be righteous/ good, all knowledge of un-righteousness / evil must ve purged.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        That sounds like an offshoot of the “name it and claim it” ideology.

        It’s a logistical disconnect, and here’s why.

        Does removing all thoughts about hazards make one more, or less safe as they navigate the terrain before them?

        It’s dangerous because there is a germ of truth to it, which is similar to what I’ve been telling you. Failure produces awareness of failure, and if improperly processed through the Primitive mind will program us to find even more of it.

        One has to set up a scenario of consciously escaping it, without inadvertently increasing the anxiety associated with it ( which the Primitive brain reads as “significant meaning”. The effort to erase that which cannot be erased, actually reinforces it)

        Erasing it???

        Good luck with that! One would have an easier time trying to erase a fundamental brain process that evolved over millions of years. And worse, it’s the selfsame process that successful people use to program themselves unto greater success.

        It also seems to be saying that someone who has never had any experience/thought of poverty, cannot fall into it.

        And that is absurd!

        If you have a book like that my friend toss it out. Someone is getting rich off of feeding logical disconnects to the people who are most susceptible to them but can least afford them.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • Jear77 says:

        @griz doesn’t the bible talk about that? “Whatever is good, pure (etc)… think *only* about such things” – only precludes thinking about anything that is sinful, nor even anything prohibited – only to the good!

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @Jear77
        One can render that by extracting parts out of the whole.

        Absolute purity of thought is the Divine standard that is reached for. Apparently forgiving AND forgetting is also a Divine standard.

        So how are you doing with absolutely forgetting every evil thing that has ever happened to you at the hands of another, hmm? Absolutely “remembering them not”? The human standard seems to be going out of our way to nurture them and keep them alive even at Great personal cost.

        The same Bible ( possibly even the same book of the Bible!) also says that none is perfect no not one. And that despite our best [solo] efforts, all fall short of the glory of God. (Which doesn’t mean it’s a bad standard to reach for; but to realize that if we think we’ve achieved it we probably have not yet; for it is transcendent. And while our Foolish Pride might seem to be transcendent, it is not. It just transcends truth and reason!)

        If one removes these two verses ( and probably a lot more), one can go to town on the one verse and have it rendering the ideologies that they like rather than the Truth that sets one free.

        Free from what? Let’s jump out of Theology and spirituality back into the scientific disciplines. It frees us from the detrimental processes of subconscious self-programming than I’ve been talking about of late. You know; the ones that can program our perceptions to render the “”reality”” we’ve attached the most meaning to.

        Negative meaning or positive meaning. This is our freedom to consciously decide. And once we have, we essentially turn loose all the subconscious subpersonalities within us all the way down to the Primitive brain . . . To make our Command . . . so

        Reply

        Loading spinner
  3. ladybarbara says:

    I think that once you step in a bear trap, you learn really fast why it is smart to watch where you are stepping.

    When you are restacking dried wood in Arizona and a big scorpion jumps out of the wood stack, you learn to look at the wood more carefully before picking it up.

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • griz says:

      @ladybarbara
      The behaviorist currently think animals learn through an interplay between the very primitive subpersonalities of fear (negative, avoidance) and curiosity (a dopamine reward process)

      With the creatures possessing a rudimentary cortex like a cat or a bear, avoidance tends to swing back to curiosity rather quickly; and the dance between the two processes can look like anxiety through our eyes. They can actually learn, but it is not under their conscious control. So it’s nothing to stress over!

      But without conscious awareness of time it’s not the same as what we experience; the negative emotion “future-fear” that leads so easily to irrational phobias and stress-related mental ailments.

      Reply

      Loading spinner
      • ladybarbara says:

        @griz After two occasions of getting stung by scorpions, I would not call the fear of a scorpion sting “irrational”. I learned to stay clear of the tail stinger. I also learned that a scorpion doesn’t like to be hit with a shovel, and a sharp hoe will chop the scorpion to pieces. All the while, staying away from that stinger. We have many in the back yard and they occasionally come walking inside the house. Immortal Pirate captures them in peanut butter jars and feeds them. The sting is quite nasty.

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • griz says:

        @ladybarbara
        I’ve never seen one in the wild, but curiosity would likely overcome fear! It’s a sign of intelligence!
        At least I think it is? Sure. Let’s go with that! :tease:

        Even after discovering I had a developing allergy to bee stings as a boy, I continued catching them in jars.

        Maybe it’s a guy thing. I had my hymenoptera collection. Immortal thinks scorpions are pets. And Davy Jones had the Kraken as his wee beastie!

        Irrational fear is debilitating. It would have you doing a Forrest Gump Marathon Across the Nation rather than taking the time to learn scorpions don’t like being hit with a shovel!

        (Pst! Most things don’t like being hit by a shovel; but I would not want to stand in the way of your conducting further scientific experimentations into the phenomenon!)

        Reply

        Loading spinner
      • ladybarbara says:

        @griz A scorpion sting cannot be compared to a bee sting. A bee sting stays in the local area of the sting. A scorpion sting has a neurological effect on your whole system. A sting on the toe goes all the way up the spinal cord to the brain —- and could kill you. The treatment is the same as a rattle snake bite. Antivenom!!! I was stung once on the bottom of the foot and another time on the toe. I have a tendency to not be a little cry-baby sissy. I don’t run to a doctor. I suck up the pain and live with it. I thought it would go away with time. Both times, it was right before my drive back to California —- plus, I did not want Immortal Pirate to know that I was stupid enough to not heed his warnings about wearing shoes at all times. I chose to be a trooper and continue on, and wait out the effects. First of all, a sting to the foot gives almost unbearable pain up to the hip joint. Walking was very hard to accomplish. I packed my car and headed out to the Interstate 10, to drive back to California. I was disoriented, as if driving drunk. I made mistakes in traffic and I had the feeling that I was lost —- even though the Interstate 10 goes all the way to Los Angeles and I only had to stay on it to get home. I stopped at gas station stops along the way and asked where I was and if I was traveling in the correct direction. I was unable to judge distances. Food had a very odd taste in my mouth and I had the feeling that everything I ate, or drank had gone rancid, or was poisonous. I kept buying food because I was hungry and then throwing it away because it tasted awful. I was a confused and mental basket case. I got myself home and went to bed. I was tormented with nightmares!!! I went to my doctor the next day after my arrival. She said that she would have treated the sting with antivenom, had I come to her the first day. However, this was the third day and the symptoms would pass in a day, or so. I returned home and stayed in bed. On the fourth day, the world was starting to look normal again and the pain was a dull ache. Food began to taste like it should and I survived. If I had to choose between a scorpion sting and a bee sting, I’d choose the bee sting.

        Reply

        Loading spinner

Leave a Reply

Search the Site