The Normative and the abnormative

An offshoot of the sex / gender debate.

For some seven million years these have been the only two classifications of importance.
Bio-evolutionarily speaking.

Flash ahead from there to 200,000 years ago, and you can add socio-evolutionarily. The same two categories are still the only two of any importance.

Flash ahead from there to just 20,000 years ago, and you can include culture-based gender norms. And these with very logical and obvious biological underpinnings.

So where does “neutral” come? What are it’s obvious biological underpinnings?

It’s almost as if there is a concerted effort to abolish the category of abnorative ( that which cannot maintain a stable socio-biological structure).
And on what grounds other than just subjective feelings is such a radical change proposed?

So consider this: If neutral and abnormative become associated with normative, how long before the former normative becomes the abnormative??

As evidence of this consider how many people will consider my raising this, as an “abnormative process”, needing to be aggressively “selected against” by some neuvo-evolutionary avant-guard!?

Is this a wise tweak to social evolution that we are trying to enforce? And if so shouldn’t it have underpinnings more proven and stable then just subjective feelings and mock-science?

If we are going to try to fly contrary to a successful track record of millions of years of evolution biology sociology and culture, it would be wise to make sure this isn’t just an emotion-driven fad.

We are very prone to those.

2 responses to “The Normative and the abnormative”

  1. Scarlett says:

    it comes from gender identity. it comes because there are those who don’t identify with either sex. Do you make a distinction between this and racial identity? Are you aware that there isn’t a single gene separating the “white” race from the “black” race, still some people identify as white or black, and that is okay if that is there thing. I don’t think that we are in a place anymore where we need to perpetuate gender stereotypes. Let people be who they are. I think it all comes down to identity. You see yourself as spiritual, no? Should we try to stifle that part of youf if we believe it is a hoax?

    Reply

    Loading spinner
    • griz says:

      @Scarlett
      The problem with this debate is that there has been a lot of very bad and very “convenient” pseudoscience attached to it.

      In 2005 the very specific set of genes that determine skin color was discovered.
      But an autopsy done on a trans woman will show that the cells of their body are still genetically male.

      The reason I posed this obviously contentious question, is because it appears we have let our emotions and feelings run away with us on it.

      And quite interesting is the fact that Nietzsche predicted this over a hundred years ago in relation to his “God is dead and we have killed him” lament.

      Even if “religion-God” did nothing else, it presented An Almighty that was higher than our feelings and emotions.
      Without that he predicted that part of the “decomposition stench” of God, could be the proliferation of many callow emotion-based ideologies that would become as new religions; perhaps superseding logic reason and even science.

      Hello, 2018.
      University-educated “experts” rise to sway the masses with eloquently worded univariate analysis of insanely complex social realities, trying to pin them on just one factor like sex or race or power. . . Or the the assertion that the wrong brain was somehow born into the wrong body. (With only subjective feelings for evidence, as Nietzsche predicted might happen)

      If I was trying to force notions upon people and rewrite the society and perhaps even demand thought-compliance from the society as a whole, I would hope there would be a few good people who would stand up and say something.

      Reply

      Loading spinner

Leave a Reply

Search the Site