Do we owe them to take care of the planet? the economy? to not bring them into existence? is it morally ethical to bring others into existence at this point?
We older folks must have children to guide us past the piled up bull-shit in us that we can’t see around.
It’s better to have existed & lost than to have never existed at all?
We owe them a knife, a tarp, & ‘Super Karate Made Easy’ by Moja Rone, once they’re old enough to know better than to go around poking people in the peepers.
Our species has seen such historical dark times and atrocities as to send a large portion of young adults into fits of moral exhibitionism and fleeing for safe spaces.
Yet our species has always endured and seen brighter days. And a part of that may involve letting the family lines who want to virtue-signal away future Generations, go extinct. Voluntary sterilization may prove and effective protest!
Let those who want to live actual virtuous lives, exercising responsible procreation and the forms of child-rearing that have proven historically effective, parent a brighter future
@Jear77
To the postmodernist, not even they can say! Because value is non-existent — except where it deemed absent when it’s not something they like in the moment.
(Just one of the major downfalls to that perceptual system).
But outside of the mental hospital of transcendent subjectivity, most people can identify a brighter day when they see it. And better still if that person has a stable set of value perceptions instantiated over time.
@griz i can. But reality can’t match my expectations. And it’s based on the understanding that there’s certain categories of things that simply can’t exist if things are to be called better. And most of these categories are unchangeable.
@griz what would it take to eliminate homelessness? Unemployment? Every disease known (and unknown!) to man? Pain? Death? (And yes i know that you believe there’s something greater on the other side, but the reality us you’re not rushing get there, so that argument is bogus)
@Jear77
I also believe there is value in what is currently here before us even if we cannot see it.
It’s hard to see if one cannot allow that it may be.
It’s impossible if one is convinced there is nothing there to see.
And it’s hell for the person who is convince themselves it is malevolently stacked against them.
@griz i’m a realist. Yes there is a small, almost unnoticeable measure of good… but that good is outweighed, overwhelmed, consumed by so many ills that i menrioned in my previous response. In the real world light holds darkness at bay… but darkness is the resting state of everything, and will always return. Looking at the world with rose colored glasses only sets you up for disappointment, hurt.
@Jear77
The realist is the person who courageously sets forth into the “what is” rather than looks for reasons why they cannot, or who to blame for it.
One can also be a realist without being a quitter or defeatist.
One can say they are something. But if they don’t walk it out they are playing a disingenuous game. We are, what we act out.
“Life, and Life more abundantly” IS the “God-Concept”. To seek reasons why “it is not” makes one the destroyer of Life: both personally and collectively.
(I can break that one down psychologically if you’d like)
Life is what it is. But we get to creatively “skew” it according to what we actively seek out. Seek out the worst, and one creates something akin to hell within and around them.
@griz i understand fully what is. Not looking for it, i was in a situation where i lived in a sewer water flooded apartment because the streets were fixed, the landlord let the electricity go off, our place was broken into not once, but twice on back to back days. According to your theory, i somehow knew the future and actively sought out apartments that would flood, landlords who would allow the electricity to be turned off and who would be so petty as to steal our stuff or hire someone to break in… or sought neighbors who would do so. Even as a thing of subconscious, that is tbe furthest thing from the truth… because if i did think any of those things, i’d be locked away in the crazy house with a straitjacket. Trust me when i say that i am not that crazy. So if these things happen to those who don’t want them in any way, shape or form, this “life” you keep talking about is ill equipped to deal with such situations.
@Jear77
So was the sewage flooded apartment a better or worst? What did you choose to create in response to it? Something more Heavenly or something more hellish?
To say that we cannot discern what is better and worse is the masturbatory schtick of post-modernism.
There is good evidence that a series of downturns (whether random or invited) can produce a depressive state in anyone. And is that this depressive state then can actively alter perceptions and expectations that tend to call forth more of the same from reality: the downward spiral of depression.
It’s also interesting that Transcendent spiritual belief is what had the best chance of bringing people through and out of such depressive states, particularly before antidepressants.
Which in hindsight could quite easily be seen as part of Nietzsche’s lament regarding the death of God (transcendent spiritual belief).
Despite his controversial critiques against organized religion, he recognized the value of the purer aspect of it — and how we would suffer in their absence.
@griz everything is a tradeoff. Nothing is perfect. Even when you’re at the top of the world, something in your life is totally fucked. To be unable to understand that is foolish. That’s why my response is to limit, shrink, reduce my world so less can go wrong.
@Jear77
Utopian expectations are foolish; as is using the aspects of the “what is” that are beyond our affecting to make our life worse rather than better.
Or using them as justification to withdraw into a smaller and smaller prison cell.
Anyone who doesn’t face the uncertainties of existential reality in their own hero’s quest, proceeds deeper and deeper into a living hell. No matter how bad things are, you can always choose to make them even a bit better, or magnitudes worse. And even if things are good beyond reckoning, you still have the power to make them even a little bit better . . . or magnitudes worse.
@griz 4 hours of travel daily long term is problematic, and damaging to the health. Better to work in my hometown unil I am able to figure things out. Likely just permanently alienated a friend of 14 years yesterday because i couldn’t help him with his business as needed time to take care of me.
@Jear77
Here’s an applied example of how we can use truthful speech (or thought) to create a new order out of the chaos and find that “it is good”.
A friend who is alienated by the reality of there being needs afoot that are not “just his”, is perhaps someone we are better off away from.
You said something in another post about what use order is if one has to constantly tend it. Better the order that requires a bit (or even a lot?) of intentional tending on our terms . . . than the chaos that requires constant reactionary attention to its whims on its terms.
Utopian fantasies aside, both require our energy input. The former tends to require an outlay up front (investment) to get it started, but then requires less and less to keep it going.
The latter tends to requires less in in the short-term; but a lot more in the mid to long term. Consider for example, the energy necessary to construct defenses against truthful speech and thought . . . and then the energy to deal with the incongruities and cognitive dissonance they produce in the psyche. It turns out to be a lot more energy than we realize, because it tends to build up over time.
Catastrophes, trials and set-backs will come no matter which path we choose. But the wise path leaves us better able to insulate ourselves from them, and better able to rebuilt after them. (both financially and psychologically)
Even if they knock us back to absolute zero (which rarely happens), a person on the wise path will already have a model for what has worked. Whereas his foolish neighbor will have no insulation, no resources, no concept of even where to begin.
@griz keep in mind that utopian visions could well fall under the umbrella of “greater things” promised by the bible! That it doesn’t makes one suspect that a god who promised these things isn’t as all powerful,all wise, or all knowing as it claims.
@Jear77
Again we’re back to the model of “toxic parenting” where the child is taught that everything will be done for them and they don’t need to reach for adult competency and responsibility for whatever situation they find themselves in. They just have to pout and gripe!
It’s classic “If at first you don’t succeed, blame it on the parents”.
The Bible does speak in Utopian language — but makes it abundantly clear exactly what prevents this: and how to start addressing it unto the adult state I mention above.
@griz but keep in mind that a bit of power would go a long way in helping this along, making it easier on believers? God is supposedly way more powerful than Galactus, yet we can’t get even half the silver surfer’s powers? That’s total bullshit.
@Jear77
Again, consider the example of children. “Making things easy for them” is what both helicopter and now bulldozer parents do — and the child suffers for it in the long run.
Some things break when stressed or knocked around (a glass). Others are resilient and neither break nor are better with stressors (a plastic tumbler). But some things like Humans, our immune system, particularly children, are made better by stressors effectively managed.
What is “made easier” by acting as if the supposition of Jesus and God is correct, is effective management of stressors.
@griz if put into RPG terms… most people in real life would have like 4 hp. In D&D it’d be that of a mage. VERY squishy. Compare that with low level superhero powers. No contest.
@Jear77
The disconnect when it relate to the paradigm of Life (Christ said “I am the way the truth and the life”) is that there is a participation with Life and not just an over-riding of it to our ego’s wishes.
That’s something akin to the “wide path” that leads to destruction. Because so many of the things that we “feel” are not accurate; and so many of the things we “like” are based mostly in short-term gratification with no concern for participation with the greater whole over time.
Bluntly put, we are selfish and foolish; wanting everything to be of us, by us, and for us with no concern for anything beyond us. (Even if there is semblance of this extending to a loved one, immediate family, a social group . . . the selfish motivation is not under control but merely concealed: dressed up for example, as the abundant dog-whistling and virtue-signalling we see today.
@griz so? If we are selfish and foolish, it’s because those proclivities were there when man was created. It goes back to not making something and then complaining about what you made. Simple acceptance would be a far better path than trying to change an entire species to be that which it is not, and condemning to rest because you weren’t wise enough to see your mistake.
@Jear77
“The Knowledge of Good and Evil” . . . was just that.
Without this there can be no freedom. Only the programming of instincts. (Rendering only a functional 1/2 a human being).
Which ironically is the very thing that destroys enlightenment, and has the Biblical label of “sin” (missing the mark) applied to it.
Humanity is a progression. We don’t suddenly cease to be from . . . where we are from!
But we can beneficially integrate where we’re from . . . into a more enlightened structure/future.
And interestingly enough, a large number of mental/psychological illness, crime, atrocity results when “where we’re from” is denied, blocked, subsumes the newer evolved aspects of Human consciousness, or is not properly integrated.
This stuff all ties together into a very tight and robust structure off of which a highly successful life can be built (recognizing that finances are just one of the games within the meta-game of a successful life).
@griz actually that too is BS. Unless we have omniscience, we can’t truly know the scope of our actions. An abortion can stop a would be mass murderer… or it could cause us to never have a xure for AIDS. A kind word might save someone’s life, but would it always? What about being mean to someone? It might toughen them .. or it might cause them to snap, bringing back a gun to shoot up a place. We never can know all the ripples of our actions.
For the most part, for them not to exist. If we can’t solve the world’s problems, what business do we have in bringing life into this,workd to create more?
@griz if you can’t solve your own problems satisfactorily (and trust me, any solutions are only band aid fixes in the long run), you’re doing nothing but giving the world a burden, more problems by choosing to procreate. Remember that i give a negative value on having existed.
@Jear77
Yes, I know there are those who are prone to waste a wonderful gift.
But I agree that if one is perversely burdened by their own issues of upbringing unresolved it would be questionable to procreate. I’m speaking of people of sound upbringing who though not problem-free, are confident in their ability to create some stable order from the chaos.
(Which is actually one of the functions of “a creator”. Even if just a “little creator” made in the image of a larger one).
@griz so your socks, underwear neat and your life a disaater is preferable to everything beibg a disaster including your socks & underwear? If my/ your whole life were disastrous, the last thing i’d / you’d need to be concerned about is the neatness of my/ your clothes!
@Jear77
There’s value to be found in knowing exactly where to find a clean pair of socks or underwear when you really need them!
And the seed of organization that starts there, can spread outwards. Maybe you start having an organized place for your keys, or your important papers so less time is spent hunting and fretting for them.
And then this spreads outwards.
But if it doesn’t start somewhere — even after a life-altering catastrophe — chaos reigns.
Remember, the Original Creative Event is said to have started with the Logos speaking truthful Order into the Chaos and finding “it was good”. And from this, Life had a place to land and flourish.
You do not know what tomorrow will bring, and do not know how the problems of today will be solved. (Nor even what the real problems of the world are.)
You have to know what the real problems of the world are, first. And you have to know what the real possible solutions are.
If someone gets sick, you can look it up online and try and diagnosis your self, but even then, you may likely not be able to prescribe the medicine for them. And even if you, could, you would not know the best medicine for them.
The problems with the world, however, are far more complex then this, as is the solution.
People do not seem to worry too much about the fact that they are dying, for one thing. They just assume it will be okay, and do not really try and think about it.
39 responses to “what do we owe people who do not exist yet?”
We older folks must have children to guide us past the piled up bull-shit in us that we can’t see around.
It’s better to have existed & lost than to have never existed at all?
We owe them a knife, a tarp, & ‘Super Karate Made Easy’ by Moja Rone, once they’re old enough to know better than to go around poking people in the peepers.
Oh and LoVe, lots of it…..
Our species has seen such historical dark times and atrocities as to send a large portion of young adults into fits of moral exhibitionism and fleeing for safe spaces.
Yet our species has always endured and seen brighter days. And a part of that may involve letting the family lines who want to virtue-signal away future Generations, go extinct. Voluntary sterilization may prove and effective protest!
Let those who want to live actual virtuous lives, exercising responsible procreation and the forms of child-rearing that have proven historically effective, parent a brighter future
@griz are there actually brighter days… or is this false hope, akin to fool’s gold tbat looks good, but is at day’s end, worthless?
@Jear77
Almost everyone succeeds at not finding that which they don’t bother seeking.
@griz The question then becomes what qualifies as brighter days? Who makes that determination?
@Jear77
To the postmodernist, not even they can say! Because value is non-existent — except where it deemed absent when it’s not something they like in the moment.
(Just one of the major downfalls to that perceptual system).
But outside of the mental hospital of transcendent subjectivity, most people can identify a brighter day when they see it. And better still if that person has a stable set of value perceptions instantiated over time.
@griz i can. But reality can’t match my expectations. And it’s based on the understanding that there’s certain categories of things that simply can’t exist if things are to be called better. And most of these categories are unchangeable.
@Jear77
Is that’s reality’s job???
As for these categories being unchangeable?
One rarely fares well at the race one doesn’t train for; or the game that they play at just the most superficial level.
@griz what would it take to eliminate homelessness? Unemployment? Every disease known (and unknown!) to man? Pain? Death? (And yes i know that you believe there’s something greater on the other side, but the reality us you’re not rushing get there, so that argument is bogus)
@Jear77
I also believe there is value in what is currently here before us even if we cannot see it.
It’s hard to see if one cannot allow that it may be.
It’s impossible if one is convinced there is nothing there to see.
And it’s hell for the person who is convince themselves it is malevolently stacked against them.
@griz i’m a realist. Yes there is a small, almost unnoticeable measure of good… but that good is outweighed, overwhelmed, consumed by so many ills that i menrioned in my previous response. In the real world light holds darkness at bay… but darkness is the resting state of everything, and will always return. Looking at the world with rose colored glasses only sets you up for disappointment, hurt.
@Jear77
The realist is the person who courageously sets forth into the “what is” rather than looks for reasons why they cannot, or who to blame for it.
One can also be a realist without being a quitter or defeatist.
One can say they are something. But if they don’t walk it out they are playing a disingenuous game. We are, what we act out.
“Life, and Life more abundantly” IS the “God-Concept”. To seek reasons why “it is not” makes one the destroyer of Life: both personally and collectively.
(I can break that one down psychologically if you’d like)
Life is what it is. But we get to creatively “skew” it according to what we actively seek out. Seek out the worst, and one creates something akin to hell within and around them.
This is our right and our responsibility.
@griz i understand fully what is. Not looking for it, i was in a situation where i lived in a sewer water flooded apartment because the streets were fixed, the landlord let the electricity go off, our place was broken into not once, but twice on back to back days. According to your theory, i somehow knew the future and actively sought out apartments that would flood, landlords who would allow the electricity to be turned off and who would be so petty as to steal our stuff or hire someone to break in… or sought neighbors who would do so. Even as a thing of subconscious, that is tbe furthest thing from the truth… because if i did think any of those things, i’d be locked away in the crazy house with a straitjacket. Trust me when i say that i am not that crazy. So if these things happen to those who don’t want them in any way, shape or form, this “life” you keep talking about is ill equipped to deal with such situations.
@Jear77
So was the sewage flooded apartment a better or worst? What did you choose to create in response to it? Something more Heavenly or something more hellish?
To say that we cannot discern what is better and worse is the masturbatory schtick of post-modernism.
There is good evidence that a series of downturns (whether random or invited) can produce a depressive state in anyone. And is that this depressive state then can actively alter perceptions and expectations that tend to call forth more of the same from reality: the downward spiral of depression.
It’s also interesting that Transcendent spiritual belief is what had the best chance of bringing people through and out of such depressive states, particularly before antidepressants.
Which in hindsight could quite easily be seen as part of Nietzsche’s lament regarding the death of God (transcendent spiritual belief).
Despite his controversial critiques against organized religion, he recognized the value of the purer aspect of it — and how we would suffer in their absence.
@griz everything is a tradeoff. Nothing is perfect. Even when you’re at the top of the world, something in your life is totally fucked. To be unable to understand that is foolish. That’s why my response is to limit, shrink, reduce my world so less can go wrong.
@Jear77
Utopian expectations are foolish; as is using the aspects of the “what is” that are beyond our affecting to make our life worse rather than better.
Or using them as justification to withdraw into a smaller and smaller prison cell.
Anyone who doesn’t face the uncertainties of existential reality in their own hero’s quest, proceeds deeper and deeper into a living hell. No matter how bad things are, you can always choose to make them even a bit better, or magnitudes worse. And even if things are good beyond reckoning, you still have the power to make them even a little bit better . . . or magnitudes worse.
@griz 4 hours of travel daily long term is problematic, and damaging to the health. Better to work in my hometown unil I am able to figure things out. Likely just permanently alienated a friend of 14 years yesterday because i couldn’t help him with his business as needed time to take care of me.
@Jear77
Here’s an applied example of how we can use truthful speech (or thought) to create a new order out of the chaos and find that “it is good”.
A friend who is alienated by the reality of there being needs afoot that are not “just his”, is perhaps someone we are better off away from.
You said something in another post about what use order is if one has to constantly tend it. Better the order that requires a bit (or even a lot?) of intentional tending on our terms . . . than the chaos that requires constant reactionary attention to its whims on its terms.
Utopian fantasies aside, both require our energy input. The former tends to require an outlay up front (investment) to get it started, but then requires less and less to keep it going.
The latter tends to requires less in in the short-term; but a lot more in the mid to long term. Consider for example, the energy necessary to construct defenses against truthful speech and thought . . . and then the energy to deal with the incongruities and cognitive dissonance they produce in the psyche. It turns out to be a lot more energy than we realize, because it tends to build up over time.
Catastrophes, trials and set-backs will come no matter which path we choose. But the wise path leaves us better able to insulate ourselves from them, and better able to rebuilt after them. (both financially and psychologically)
Even if they knock us back to absolute zero (which rarely happens), a person on the wise path will already have a model for what has worked. Whereas his foolish neighbor will have no insulation, no resources, no concept of even where to begin.
@griz keep in mind that utopian visions could well fall under the umbrella of “greater things” promised by the bible! That it doesn’t makes one suspect that a god who promised these things isn’t as all powerful,all wise, or all knowing as it claims.
@Jear77
Again we’re back to the model of “toxic parenting” where the child is taught that everything will be done for them and they don’t need to reach for adult competency and responsibility for whatever situation they find themselves in. They just have to pout and gripe!
It’s classic “If at first you don’t succeed, blame it on the parents”.
The Bible does speak in Utopian language — but makes it abundantly clear exactly what prevents this: and how to start addressing it unto the adult state I mention above.
@griz but keep in mind that a bit of power would go a long way in helping this along, making it easier on believers? God is supposedly way more powerful than Galactus, yet we can’t get even half the silver surfer’s powers? That’s total bullshit.
@Jear77
Again, consider the example of children. “Making things easy for them” is what both helicopter and now bulldozer parents do — and the child suffers for it in the long run.
Some things break when stressed or knocked around (a glass). Others are resilient and neither break nor are better with stressors (a plastic tumbler). But some things like Humans, our immune system, particularly children, are made better by stressors effectively managed.
What is “made easier” by acting as if the supposition of Jesus and God is correct, is effective management of stressors.
(And perhaps even the stray “super-power”!)
@griz if put into RPG terms… most people in real life would have like 4 hp. In D&D it’d be that of a mage. VERY squishy. Compare that with low level superhero powers. No contest.
@Jear77
The disconnect when it relate to the paradigm of Life (Christ said “I am the way the truth and the life”) is that there is a participation with Life and not just an over-riding of it to our ego’s wishes.
That’s something akin to the “wide path” that leads to destruction. Because so many of the things that we “feel” are not accurate; and so many of the things we “like” are based mostly in short-term gratification with no concern for participation with the greater whole over time.
Bluntly put, we are selfish and foolish; wanting everything to be of us, by us, and for us with no concern for anything beyond us. (Even if there is semblance of this extending to a loved one, immediate family, a social group . . . the selfish motivation is not under control but merely concealed: dressed up for example, as the abundant dog-whistling and virtue-signalling we see today.
@griz so? If we are selfish and foolish, it’s because those proclivities were there when man was created. It goes back to not making something and then complaining about what you made. Simple acceptance would be a far better path than trying to change an entire species to be that which it is not, and condemning to rest because you weren’t wise enough to see your mistake.
@Jear77
“The Knowledge of Good and Evil” . . . was just that.
Without this there can be no freedom. Only the programming of instincts. (Rendering only a functional 1/2 a human being).
Which ironically is the very thing that destroys enlightenment, and has the Biblical label of “sin” (missing the mark) applied to it.
Humanity is a progression. We don’t suddenly cease to be from . . . where we are from!
But we can beneficially integrate where we’re from . . . into a more enlightened structure/future.
And interestingly enough, a large number of mental/psychological illness, crime, atrocity results when “where we’re from” is denied, blocked, subsumes the newer evolved aspects of Human consciousness, or is not properly integrated.
This stuff all ties together into a very tight and robust structure off of which a highly successful life can be built (recognizing that finances are just one of the games within the meta-game of a successful life).
@griz actually that too is BS. Unless we have omniscience, we can’t truly know the scope of our actions. An abortion can stop a would be mass murderer… or it could cause us to never have a xure for AIDS. A kind word might save someone’s life, but would it always? What about being mean to someone? It might toughen them .. or it might cause them to snap, bringing back a gun to shoot up a place. We never can know all the ripples of our actions.
@Jear77
Certain ideologies try to cast it as BS.
But the inability to be the “ultimate expression” of something beneficial, in no way prevents us from participating unto that partial or ultimate end.
Or learning from our mistakes when what we thought might be good or “better”, turns out not to be!
It’s called LIFE and learning.
For the most part, for them not to exist. If we can’t solve the world’s problems, what business do we have in bringing life into this,workd to create more?
@Jear77
By those parameters the race would never have existed.
Neither would any life.
Destroyer much?
@griz if you can’t solve your own problems satisfactorily (and trust me, any solutions are only band aid fixes in the long run), you’re doing nothing but giving the world a burden, more problems by choosing to procreate. Remember that i give a negative value on having existed.
@Jear77
Yes, I know there are those who are prone to waste a wonderful gift.
But I agree that if one is perversely burdened by their own issues of upbringing unresolved it would be questionable to procreate. I’m speaking of people of sound upbringing who though not problem-free, are confident in their ability to create some stable order from the chaos.
(Which is actually one of the functions of “a creator”. Even if just a “little creator” made in the image of a larger one).
@griz ultimate order is unobtainable. We live in a world where entropy always wins.
@Jear77
But a small corner of order is better than none at all.
@griz what good is order when it constantly needs to be propped up?
@Jear77
Levels of goodness that cannot be realized in a board game.
Or a utopian fantasy!
@griz so your socks, underwear neat and your life a disaater is preferable to everything beibg a disaster including your socks & underwear? If my/ your whole life were disastrous, the last thing i’d / you’d need to be concerned about is the neatness of my/ your clothes!
@Jear77
There’s value to be found in knowing exactly where to find a clean pair of socks or underwear when you really need them!
And the seed of organization that starts there, can spread outwards. Maybe you start having an organized place for your keys, or your important papers so less time is spent hunting and fretting for them.
And then this spreads outwards.
But if it doesn’t start somewhere — even after a life-altering catastrophe — chaos reigns.
Remember, the Original Creative Event is said to have started with the Logos speaking truthful Order into the Chaos and finding “it was good”. And from this, Life had a place to land and flourish.
You do not know what tomorrow will bring, and do not know how the problems of today will be solved. (Nor even what the real problems of the world are.)
You have to know what the real problems of the world are, first. And you have to know what the real possible solutions are.
If someone gets sick, you can look it up online and try and diagnosis your self, but even then, you may likely not be able to prescribe the medicine for them. And even if you, could, you would not know the best medicine for them.
The problems with the world, however, are far more complex then this, as is the solution.
People do not seem to worry too much about the fact that they are dying, for one thing. They just assume it will be okay, and do not really try and think about it.