The barter system worked well enough for arguably millions of years for Humans. But it was improved upon by ancients by the idea of “wampum” (currency). That’s FAR easier to carry around than 1/2 a Phoenix duplex for a year!
While it certainly can be an interesting hobby to try to get barter to work as well as currency, moving “stuff” around all over has an expense. While I appreciate the optimism of this fellow in mostly reporting on the positive “upgrades”, consider the expenses in driving/flying all over to effect these trades. He mentions the fuel economy of the Cintas truck, but to move it he would have had to transfer title to this name and licence AND insure it as a commercial vehicle — which is costly.
So the value of his “item” went up, but only through the constant dumping of his own money “from elsewhere” into the equation.
While a currency system is not perfect, it certainly does have streamlining advantages. I am essentially “bartering” for my house — only with currency that I generate by sacrificing my time (life) to something I mostly enjoy.
But I’m one-up on this fellow, because under the current system I can write off expenses incurred in the process of my making money with which to “trade for” a lovely home.
The home is already mine to use and enjoy — and even provides equity to make other opportunities possible.
Whereas he could still be sitting on a KISS glow-globe wondering when he’ll get an actual roof over his head.
@griz the ted talk was about a number of successive trades, it went from a paperclip for a pen, eventually to a snowmobile to a generator, a day with a rock star to a snow globe, and the final trade was a starring part in a movie for a house. I think the beauty of it was for the most part, he didn’t know what he was going to get. I wonder if i could perform a similar experiment to get a job/ career i can live off of.
@Jear77
To that I can only say, look at how much money he was out in fuel, time, insurance, registration etc. He definitely got something better than what he started with. But he was feeding (bleeding?) money into the equation constantly to keep it running.
It’s a classic “Great output, for little input” scenario. They make for good dreams; but rarely put food on the table or a roof over your head.
I’m glad I waited to answer this because my first thought was a paper clip holding my important papers together in a bunch. To have to set a whole house on the papers to hold them together …. well, a paper clip is easier and fits in my file drawer easier than a whole house would.
Regarding your clarification below, the exchange cycle is similar to nonbarter systems. You can turn five dollars into a hundred thousand, if you are lucky. Risk is involved in investments, higher risk can bring higher profit. Or loss.
6 responses to “What if you could trade a paperclip for a house?”
The barter system worked well enough for arguably millions of years for Humans. But it was improved upon by ancients by the idea of “wampum” (currency). That’s FAR easier to carry around than 1/2 a Phoenix duplex for a year!
While it certainly can be an interesting hobby to try to get barter to work as well as currency, moving “stuff” around all over has an expense. While I appreciate the optimism of this fellow in mostly reporting on the positive “upgrades”, consider the expenses in driving/flying all over to effect these trades. He mentions the fuel economy of the Cintas truck, but to move it he would have had to transfer title to this name and licence AND insure it as a commercial vehicle — which is costly.
So the value of his “item” went up, but only through the constant dumping of his own money “from elsewhere” into the equation.
While a currency system is not perfect, it certainly does have streamlining advantages. I am essentially “bartering” for my house — only with currency that I generate by sacrificing my time (life) to something I mostly enjoy.
But I’m one-up on this fellow, because under the current system I can write off expenses incurred in the process of my making money with which to “trade for” a lovely home.
The home is already mine to use and enjoy — and even provides equity to make other opportunities possible.
Whereas he could still be sitting on a KISS glow-globe wondering when he’ll get an actual roof over his head.
@griz the ted talk was about a number of successive trades, it went from a paperclip for a pen, eventually to a snowmobile to a generator, a day with a rock star to a snow globe, and the final trade was a starring part in a movie for a house. I think the beauty of it was for the most part, he didn’t know what he was going to get. I wonder if i could perform a similar experiment to get a job/ career i can live off of.
@Jear77
To that I can only say, look at how much money he was out in fuel, time, insurance, registration etc. He definitely got something better than what he started with. But he was feeding (bleeding?) money into the equation constantly to keep it running.
It’s a classic “Great output, for little input” scenario. They make for good dreams; but rarely put food on the table or a roof over your head.
I’m glad I waited to answer this because my first thought was a paper clip holding my important papers together in a bunch. To have to set a whole house on the papers to hold them together …. well, a paper clip is easier and fits in my file drawer easier than a whole house would.
Regarding your clarification below, the exchange cycle is similar to nonbarter systems. You can turn five dollars into a hundred thousand, if you are lucky. Risk is involved in investments, higher risk can bring higher profit. Or loss.
Trick is managing risk, to get the better deal.
That is the field I work in.