If you had to be reincarnated after death as the member of any oppressed group, what would you choose? Hispanic, African American, Native American, LGBTQ, etc.?
White privilege defined:
“White privilege refers to any advantage, opportunity, benefit, head start, or general protection from negative societal mistreatment, which persons deemed white will typically enjoy, but which others will generally not enjoy. These benefits can be material (such as greater opportunity in the labor market, or greater net worth, due to a history in which whites had the ability to accumulate wealth to a greater extent than persons of color), social (such as presumptions of competence, creditworthiness, law-abidingness, intelligence, etc.) or psychological (such as not having to worry about triggering negative stereotypes, rarely having to feel out of place, not having to worry about racial profiling, etc.).” – Tim Wise
© 2026 – SoulSequel
44 responses to “White privilege”
There’s a point in which looking at such topics is problematic. If something is offensive that’s one thing… but doesn’t necessarily constitute as racist, sexist, etc. Consider that African Americans use the “N” word all the time. So just by a person not of the same race using that word, should it make the person totally lose it and collapse into a blubbering mess, even if it’s offensive? Does that mean that if the shoe were on the other foot and a Caucasian were called a honkey or cracker, the white person would do the same?
@Jear77
I can deal with honky or cracker.
So long as they don’t call me a vanilla wafer. Then I’ll go WLM all over their pigmentally gifted assets!
@Jear77 you didn’t answer the q. I’ll make it easier. If you came back as another sexual orientation and/or gender other than your present, what would you choose. I would choose to be a bi-woman.
@Scarlett likely a Mexican. At least that way i would know what it is,to do hard physical labor. But also it’d be in my genes.
@Jear77
“Consider that African Americans use the “N” word all the time.”
this question and answers are extremely disappointing.
@Fletch i see a double standard and am calling it out.
@Jear77
I just really don’t like this question.
BTW you can say or write ‘nigger’ any time you want.
I just wrote it, and I am not a racist.
I may choose Native American, though I think they are killed by police at a higher rate than even black people. Terribly hard choice. Killed by police, incarcerated for stupid reasons or even fake reasons, racism of everyday people, hassled by ICE. It would be hard to be any of them. I just feel that maybe the everyday racism may be lower for NA’s? I have nothing to prove or disprove that though.
@yin
The stats show that they are at higher levels of scrutiny and even persecution than caucasians.
So I would take that into consideration: keeping my nose extra clean, thinking twice before engaging in criminal activity, and working to avoid even the appearance of it. (Which is good advice for anyone)
I would work towards becoming an MVP in the game that was being played.
And if I wanted to play my own different game, I would go find a suitable field and not try to take over theirs.
@griz I just knew them dying by police. I was going with the idea of rather being killed in an instant than being continuously locked up for dumb stuff so the cops can meet quotas, ruining my life. Maybe they get arrested and harassed more as well (which would make sense considered how they are killed), so it really doesn’t matter which to pick. Overall, I don’t care what race I am. I will be who I am.
@yin
I don’t doubt that police predation is worse in the United States than in Canada. Boss Hogg is a case in point!
But is it as bad as the various victimhood groups are playing it up? Insistence is that I cannot know because I am white.
But I do know that I am going to be at higher risk of a suspicion if I have a guilty conscience; and of a forceful encounter if I don’t respect the officers authority, resist them, flee, have a weapon, or want to turn it into a head-butting political statement.
@yin I think it would be interesting to be native american, to learn about the culture. I like some of their spiral beliefs, earthiness.
Being a member of any group that is not dominant within a given culture would come with similar challenges that one could wrestle into wisdom; so I would welcome any of them.
Personally I would choose Native Canadian simply because I am familiar with it.
Consider though, that there is nothing “demon” about being a Caucasian in a culture founded by Caucasians. If I was a minority in a society founded by Asians, I would both expect and concede certain challenges based on my race.
Even if they said, “Welcome! You are as family” I would not expect the full considerations of family until I had journeyed with them for a while. And certainly not if I disrespected their home by trying to alter it to my liking.
There is something rather “self-precious” in boarding a ship mid Journey and instantly expecting all the considerations of someone who helped build the ship.
Or in expecting inherent elements of human nature to just wink out because “”I”” have arrived.
Both rights and privileges . . . come with responsibilities.
If you are not receiving the former, it is good to ask if you are living up to the latter. And if you are, in more than just your own eyes, you may have a valid issue to put forth.
@griz not sure about all that. Were you aware race is a modern idea? Ancient greeks separated people based on color, but actually race is a modern idea, a social construct. There are actually no differences in the genetic makeup of the races.
@Scarlett
You just confused me with this one. Nations were the first racial groups. And they have been discriminating against each other and warring since the beginning of time.
You will have to explain what you mean by it being a recent social construct.
I am not sure the purpose of this? White guilt?
I would want to come back as a pure white baby seal —— with vicious teeth!
@ladybarbara obviously white
@Fletch . I have been a Native American all of this life. I am a registered Modoc. So, I will choose to be a baby seal. I have never lived as a “white”, being that every member of my tribe has to be registered and counted for.
@ladybarbara I think you make things up.
@saintcharlie Well, we are being asked a question — to choose an oppressed to be. So yes, I made it up that I want to be a baby seal of pure white and have poachers after me. Yes I made that up. I don’t really want to be a seal. I am already an American Indian and my family is required to register as Native Americans. However, my family members can look white, some of us look Hispanic and we could pass for Hispanic. I am one of the lighter skinned members of my family, but I am only 3rd generation after the Modoc War. My grandmother was born in the last days of the Modoc war. My Great Grandmother and her baby were forced into slavery and taken to the Mission in San Diego to be servants to the nuns, until they were PURCHASED by “white men”. My Grandmother was purchased by Stephen T. Mather and had 14 children by him. The rest of the Modoc tribe is in Klamath, Oregon on a reservation. There are 50 of the lineage of Kintpaush who were taken to Oklahoma reservations to separate them from the Northern California tribe members that were placed in Oregon. The reason why my Great Grandmother and her baby were separated from the rest of the tribe, was because she was being raised in the family of Kintpaush, the Chief of the Modoc tribe as his daughter. Her heritage was Castilian (Spanish) and she was the surviving baby after her parents were massicurred in the wagon train massicure at Fandango Pass. Her name was Cecealia Chicon. I don’t know what name the tribe gave her. However, my Grandmother’s father was known as Hooker Jim of the Modoc tribe. I know my family heritage on my Grandmother’s bloodline
@ladybarbara Ok Barb.
@saintcharlie Well, just giving you facts that can be looked up and investigated. You like to call me a liar and there is nothing I can do about it, but give facts. I know I am not liked on this site and do not know why I go through the punishment of coming to a site where I am demonized.
Definitely Hispanic because I like to SALSA, but my sorta white butt doesn’t gyrate correctly.
Truth is, I can probably relate to what it’s like to not experience white privileged, but perhaps in not such an acute manner as those of colour or sexual orientation that is not considered status quo.
I have had to worker harder for promotions because, like it or not, a taller, blue eyed fuck ups would get promoted ahead of me on enough occasions for me to know I had to work twice as hard for half the recognition (I’m able to empathize with women on that score.)
I have also experienced reverse discrimination as a white face in a black barber shop. My ‘fro required the skills of a black barber to handle my “wool”. They got used to me, but it took about four visits before anyone would talk in the shop while I was there. I used to get some pretty aggressive looks from some of the younger guys waiting their turn. Was sure I was going to catch some hell one time, but the barber, who knew me by now, lowered the tension by kidding with me enough to know I was a regular. It is very discomforting to experience a sense of being hated for no reason other than your minority colour. Having experienced first hand, to the limited degree I did, is enough for me to recognize anyone who exhibits racial biases as a total bonehead.
@spitfire3dc hispanic has some beautiful culture. Do you feel lie every time a member or group of African Americans try to use their voice or gain some ground, oppressive people are around trying to shut them up?
You live in a country that is ruled by fear. It wasn’t always like that but that is the predominant driver of pretty well all that is America.
We’ve talked about this before. Decisions are made, based on either love or fear and if you see the influence of so many policies enacted by government, is Homeland Security an organization based on love? The response to weapons of mass destruction that weren’t there? Flying bombers off the coast of North Korea, putting troops on the ground everywhere but US soil where the manpower could be used to assist citizens of the US versus alienating citizens elsewhere?
So, when you ask about the response to black people suggesting that equality is their right as much as it is the right of other American citizens; what is driving the white establishment to resist? Fear. And what does fear usually breed? Aggression based on the American way that has always illustrated that the best defense is a strong offense.
@spitfire3dc
I think there is also a lot of payback (lawsuit) thinking in America compared to the rest of the world. If someone is “collecting damages” for something a racial group did to their ancestors in the past, they are collecting it at the expense of a lot of young people who have done them no harm.
This is what happens when victimhood thinking meets lawsuit thinking.
Put the starting blocks for each generation in the same place. Disadvantaging one group to advantage the other, just repeats the trespass.
@spitfire3dc
If you didn’t SALSA naked they wouldn’t see your white butt!
(It saves on the thigh bruises too)
@Scarlett – please tell us the reason for this question? I believe it creates more harm than good. We make fun of “oh sure I don’t mind being called cracker or whitey” but it’s not true.
An explanation would be appreciated
my first thought was Give me an accent . let me be born some place warm and simple. let me be a brown old gramma on her porch peeling apples for youngsters.
my mind is going to try to expand on this question more. ill come back.
@BelleMadre that was some beautiful imagery!
@Scarlett i cant say i truly know what it feels like to be anyone other than myself, but i do know what it feels like to have slurs yelled at me across the street for you i Am. these questions might stir nests but they might also help bridge gaps, or even humanize others for us.
i Can respond from my own heart and so i try to do that. the inner grannie in me sees the inner child in you. she waves
@BelleMadre
Just remember that the people we think have accents. . . think we are the ones with the accents!
Just move away from where you were born and voila! Instant accent, y’all!
(Or make singing the universal language and all accents disappear!)
@griz
so true
whenever someone comments on my ‘accent’ i dont get it
@BelleMadre
Travel cures this!
Or does it complicate it? If I’m not paying attention I become an accent chameleon! People can think I am mocking their accent; and more than once my dad has asked me whose accent I was borrowing today!
Being NA, I think I’ve somewhat experienced Hispanic and Asian already depending on what city I’m at. So that leaves me with AA and LGBTQ. With all the stuff happening in the news, both sound pretty scary. haha. I’ll flip a coin.
Am I out of my head or is this question extremely racist?
I have asked for a comment from @Scarlett but none (it’s OK, might be blocked)
anyone else think this?
@Fletch This question kind of rubbed me the wrong way too. I see what you mean.
@saintcharlie ok good. well, not good, but you know what I’m getting at.
It’s like I have to ‘feel bad’ since I’m white. just don’t get the direction of the post.
she’s posted a few like this. i ask for clarification, get nothing.
@Fletch I think the intention behind the question was for those of us who are white face the fact that things for POC aren’t up to par right now by putting us in their shoes, but the selecting a race to come back as is strange, especially with some of the comments above picking out varying stereotypes as their rationale.
@saintcharlie
exactly
I liken it to asking:
“Hey all you oppressed people, if you didn’t have to be oppressed and could be a regular rich white person, what high paying occupation would you have? What beach city would you live in? What private schools would you send your 2.5 kids to? What oppressed group would you really feel bad for?”
a bit of a reach, I know.
I see the intent behind this question, to forcibly make those of us with privilege to consider what it would be like to walk a mile in a POC’s shoes – and this is a valiant intent – but the question in and of itself sort of rubs me the wrong way, I think. A lot of the responses are based off of stereotypes, and I don’t know, it seems perverse.
@saintcharlie I respectfully disagree with your assessment of the question and responses. I will tell you why. I think that we are probably a long way off from removing bias, stereotypes etc, but what WOULD help is if we open up a dialogue and become aware of our biases, and unite about what we can do to not let our biases affect how we treat people. People need to be aware that racism, homophobia etc are not over. They may never be over, but lets educate ourselves, and have a frank discussion of directions we can take so that these “perverse” parts of us don’t lead to “perverse” practices, i.e. redlining, blockbusting etc. That is just my opinion though, St. Charlie, and I appreciate you reading and commenting. I miss when people aren’t here. I miss people from soul pancake. they were nice and interesting people to talk to!
@Scarlett I fully agree that we’re a long way off from removing bias, stereotypes, and ills of the same breed, but marinating in these things is not the way of doing this. When you’ve got people saying “I’d probably come back as Mexicans because they’re hard workers,” that’s just more stereotyping, albeit in a positive manner. It’s a fetishization of other cultures.